Middlemarch Madness Voting Day 4: Fives v. Twelves

[E] Selena MacIntosh*Middlemarch Madness39 Comments

kindlyhippie

Hello! We survived yet another server move! This one was touch and go for awhile, I thought I’d sent our girl Persephone to the underworld for good a couple of times. Since I made you wait on Friday, when we learned we had to move, I couldn’t make you all wait until tomorrow to find out the results and get back on the Madness train. Have I built the suspense enough? Click on!

First up, Thursday night’s big winners.

YA Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Dystopia

Coraline comes around to upset Alice.

YA Fiction

In a surprise end run, Jessica “Not So” Darling defeats Melinda. (and Twitter goes wild!)

Adult Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Dystopia

Karin Murphy beats Harry (our comments go wild!)

Adult Fiction

Lady MacBeth beats Mulan (Selena goes wild, Mulan was robbed!)

Here’s your latest bracket-y goodness!

http://persephonemagazine.com/images/Middlemarchmadnessbracket4.pdf

Ready for tonight’s votes? Go!

Loading…

Related
Avatar of [E] Selena MacIntosh*
Find me on

[E] Selena MacIntosh*

Editor-in-Chief at Persephone Magazine
Selena MacIntosh is the owner and editor of Persephone Magazine. She also fixes it when it breaks. She is fueled by Diet Coke, coffee with a lot of cream in it, and cat hair.
Avatar of [E] Selena MacIntosh*
Find me on

Latest posts by [E] Selena MacIntosh* (see all)

Thanks for rating this! Now tell the world how you feel via Twitter.
What feel do you feel after reading this post?
  • Inspired
  • Smart
  • Tickled
  • Hungry
  • Sad
  • Smash!
[E] Selena MacIntosh*Middlemarch Madness Voting Day 4: Fives v. Twelves

39 Comments on “Middlemarch Madness Voting Day 4: Fives v. Twelves”

Leave a Reply

  1. Avatar of Luci Furious
    Luci Furious

    I love that Celie was pitted against Scarlett O’Hara. Sorry entitled, spoiled white bitch, you will lose.
    Is the Scarlett in the book different from in the movie? Because I don’t think movie Scarlett is likeable at all.

    1. Avatar of Amanda
      Amanda

      Unfortunately, movie Scarlett is pretty accurate as far as general Scarlett insufferability. Most unsympathetic book heroine ever.

      1. Avatar of highjump
        highjump

        I don’t think that is true at all. I think the ultimate lesson of the book is that though success/money is important and Scarlett isn’t totally wrong for doing what she did – she took it too far. Her success is hollow because in the end she has no one to share it with. Her experience of extreme poverty has warped her so much, how can you not feel bad for her? And when her child dies?! When she is raped?! When she miscarries the baby she hopes will save her marriage?! You’re seriously telling me that you don’t feel bad for her in any of these situations? Or that she ‘deserved’ it somehow? The woman grew up in a life of comfort and security and was unexpectedly thrust into a new world, in which she bravely made her way, though it made her bitter. Even as she mocked the old guard who pined for a lost time, she did the same thing herself in pining for Ashley. How can you not feel for Scarlett?

        1. Avatar of LittleGirlBlue
          LittleGirlBlue

          Eh. No one deserves abuse, but I just really struggle to empathize with a character who never saw anything but her own misfortune– even after years when she enjoyed a life of privilege that was sustained only by the misery of others.
          //endrant

    2. Avatar of bettyeff
      bettyeff

      So I was talking with a good friend of mine the other day. His grandparents are Chinese immigrants, who came from pretty poor beginnings. Their reaction to Scarlett eating the dirty turnip (or whatever) out of the ground? “Why doesn’t she just eat the horse? Such a waste!”

      Really puts that white privilege in perspective.

      Go Celie!

      1. Avatar of highjump
        highjump

        “Why doesn’t she just eat the horse?” Because she lives in an extremely rural area and needs it for transportation. They also need the horse to plow their fields so they have cotton to sell. In the book she actually walks several miles to find that turnip, she doesn’t ride around on the horse for fun. In fact there is a passage in the book where she thinks about all the horses Tara used to have, and how she can’t ride their one skinny horse anywhere because it needs to rest as much as possible.

    3. Avatar of Kit Cloudkicker
      Kit Cloudkicker

      Man, I hated Gone With the Wind. I’ve only read the book, but book Scarlett was horrible. I read it around 6th grade and remember thinking, “Wait, everyone sucks and everything goes to crap, nobody learns anything, and that’s the end?”

    4. Avatar of LittleGirlBlue
      LittleGirlBlue

      Sadly, no. The Scarlett in the book is actually a bit more annoying, if that is even possible, than the movie Scarlett, because you get to know her better.

    5. Avatar of highjump
      highjump

      Boo! Scarlett FTW! Not that the book and some of her actions aren’t problematic, but Scarlett is an amazing woman. The book Scarlett is definitely different. There is much more time spent on her getting Tara functioning again, much more time spent planning her sawmill business, and lots of internal strife over being forced to have children and having to behave like a lady in public. There is also a beautiful scene with Grandma Fontaine where she talks about how scared she is and about how part of her wants to give up and leave, but a bigger part of her wants to succeed. Scarlett isn’t about being likable, that’s the point. /rant

  2. Avatar of LadyOverseas
    LadyOverseas

    With the exception of Karana’s victory, I have lost every round. Claudia v. Scout is just cruel and Turtle v. Harriet will break my heart. But I hope it comes down (on the left side) to Lyra v. Meg v. Harriet v. Scout. I’ll never recover from Leslie’s defeat (come ON) though.

    I’m okay with everything that happens as long as Lyra comes out the champion.

    P.S. Where’s Winnie Foster? :(

    1. Avatar of [E] Selena MacIntosh*
      [E] Selena MacIntosh*

      Winnie! OMG! How did we forget her?

      The YA Fiction group is so cruel because we started with only 17 names, instead of arranging them by number of votes, like the others, I arranged them alphabetically. It makes for some vicious competition.

      1. Avatar of LadyOverseas
        LadyOverseas

        Man, that WAS vicious! I’m soo impressed with the game though. My friends and I are way too into it to admit to anyone in real life…

        Thanks for creating such an awesome competition!

    2. Avatar of Anna H.
      Anna H.

      You’re right! Where is Winnie Foster!

      I vote this becomes an annual Persephone feature, particularly so that all those left out this time around can make it in next time.

      …There was another crucial omission mentioned sometime last week, so obvious that now I’m forgetting who it was….

    1. Avatar of
      goingquietlymad

      Neil Gaiman fans will come out of every tiny hole in the woodwork if there’s voting to be done…which is why his fans are the bestest fans ever!

  3. Avatar of Eresbel
    Eresbel

    Nancy Drew? Pff. Harriet all the way.

    Also, Harriet the Spy the Movie featured Michelle Trachtenburg before her annoying stint on Buffy, which is always fun to see.

Leave a Reply