Connect with us:

A daily blog for bookish and clever women.

Test reads "Bracket"

Middlemarch Madness III: Round One, Poll Four



This is the last day of round one, by Monday we’ll only have 32 contestants left.

Today we’re pitting the 7 and 10 seeds, and the 2 and 15 seeds in all four categories.

Logo for Persephone Magazine's Middlemarch Madness

Young Adult Sci-fi/Fantasy/Dystopia

  • Seed #7 Violet BaudelaireA Series of Unfotunate Events, by Lemony Snicket v. seed #10 CimoreneEnchanted Forest quartet by Patricia Wrede
  • Seed #2 Katniss Everdeen, The Hunger Games trilogy, by Suzanne Collins v. seed #15 AnnHexwood, by Diana Wynne Jones

Click to vote.

Violet Baudelaire v. Cimorene
#7 Violet Baudelaire
vote
#10 Cimorene
vote

Katniss Everdeen v. Ann
#2 Katniss Everdeen
vote
#15 Ann
vote

Young Adult Literary Fiction

  • Seed #7 Charlotte A. CavaticaCharlotte’s Web, by E. B. White v. seed #10 KaranaIsland of the Blue Dolphins, by Scott O’Dell
  • Seed #2 HarrietHarriet the Spy, by Louise Fitzhugh v. seed #15 Anastasia KrupnikAnastasia Krupnik series, by Lois Lowry

Click to vote.

Charlotte A. Cavatica v. Karana
#7 Charlotte A. Cavatica
vote
#10 Karana
vote

Harriet v. Anastasia Krupnik
#2 Harriet
vote
#15 Anastasia Krupnik
vote

Adult Sci-fi/Fantasy/Dystopia

  • Seed #7  ClaudiaInterview with the Vampire, by Anne Rice v. seed #10 Kathy H.Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro
  • Seed #2 Daenerys TagaryenA Song of Ice and Fire series, by George R. R. Martin v. seed #15 Surreal SaDiabloBlack Jewels Trilogy, by Anne Bishop

Click to vote.

Claudia v. Kathy H.
#7 Claudia
vote
#10 Kathy H
vote

Daenerys Tagaryen v. Surreal SaDiablo
#2 Daenerys Tagaryen
vote
#15 Surreal SaDiablo
vote

Adult Literary Fiction

  • Seed #7  Cassandra,  I Capture the Castle, by Dodie Smith v. seed #10 CecilyThe Importance of Being Earnest, by Oscar Wilde
  • Seed #2 BeatriceMuch Ado About Nothing, by William Shakespeare v. seed #15 Ree DollyWinter’s Bone, by Daniel Woodrell

Click to vote. 

Cassandra v. Cecily
#7 Cassandra
vote
#10 Cecily
vote

Beatrice v. Ree Dolly
#2 Beatrice
vote
#15 Ree Dolly
vote

Thanks for rating this! Now tell the world how you feel via Twitter.

How does this post make you feel?

  • Inspired
  • Smart
  • Tickled
  • Hungry
  • Empathetic
  • Smash!

About the Author

Avatar of [E] Selena MacIntosh

[E] Selena MacIntoshSelena MacIntosh thinks you're perfect, just the way you are. She would also like a Diet Coke.View all posts by [E] Selena MacIntosh →

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  1. LadyOverseas
    LadyOverseas03-10-2013

    And how can a fictional spider (amazing though she may be) win over Karana? Karana is the ultimate survivor. She would definitely kick Katniss’ ass.

  2. LadyOverseas
    LadyOverseas03-10-2013

    WHAT. WHAT. WHAT. Kathy H?! Kathy H?!

  3. [E] Selena MacIntosh
    [E] Selena MacIntosh03-09-2013

    Votes are closed and the bracket is updated for next week!
    Middlemarch Madness III

  4. Frigg
    Frigg03-08-2013

    This one wasn’t overly difficult. The only ones I would be happy to see go far out of these ones is Harriet and Charlotte and to a lesser extent Katniss.

    Do we keep going over the weekend or does it break until Monday?

  5. Mary
    Mary03-08-2013

    Violet Baudelaire VS. Cimorene??

    Harriet the Spy VS. Anastasia Krupnik??

    You are KILLING me with these brackets.

  6. [M] QoB
    [M] QoB03-08-2013

    Oof, Ann. Bad draw. Love you anyway.

  7. BaseballChica03
    BaseballChica0303-08-2013

    WHY IS CHARLOTTE A. CAVATICA LOSING? DO YOU PEOPLE HAVE NO SOULS??? ARE YOUR HEARTS MADE OF STONE???

  8. [M] freckle
    [M] freckle03-08-2013

    Kathy H. annoyed me to no end. And I don’t recognize a lot of others, so this was an easy round.

  9. twiddle
    twiddle03-08-2013

    Beatrice is one of my favorites! (I especially love when she was played by Emma Thompson in the Kenneth Branaugh version)

    • Sheena is knitting all the things
      Sheena is knitting all the things03-08-2013

      YES. She’s especially one of my favorite women from Shakespeare, and even more one of my favorite of his heroines. It’s the intelligence and the not-being-defined-by-men that does it for me.

      • amandamarieg
        amandamarieg03-08-2013

        Plus, despite the whole, “will not be defined by men” thing, she’s not one-note, like so many of those characters are. She’s all, “No man definition, but dammit. I like that boy. FML.” You know. Like an actual woman. Plus, I love that whole scene at the masquerade where she’s teasing Claudio when he asks why she’s not married and she basically says, “If you’re so interested, how about YOU marry me, then?” And then he’s backed into a corner. Hilarious.

    • Silverwane
      Silverwane03-08-2013

      Seconded! Beatrice is awesome, and she remains awesome even when she decides to be with Benedick – which is a far cry better than, say, a lot of rom-coms!

  10. LadyOverseas
    LadyOverseas03-08-2013

    Harriet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  11. Silverwane
    Silverwane03-08-2013

    Goooo Daenerys!

    No Twitter Messages