New Show Recap

Breathe With Me: Game of Thrones Episode 9

“I grew up with soldiers… I learned how to die a long time ago”.

No prizes for guessing who said that. But before we get to him, let’s visit the Wall. Jon receives a present from Lord Commander Mormont for saving him from the zombie in the last episode: a snazzy sword of Valyrian steel, the Mormont family heirloom (which Jorah was considerate enough to leave behind before he was exiled). Jon tries to give it back, but Mormont insists, and Jon heads to the kitchens where excited Night’s Watchmen clamour for a go. Jon is a happy camper, not just because of the sword but also because meanie trainer Alliser Thorne has been sent to King’s Landing with the disembodied zombie hand and is thus not likely to wreck Jon’s buzz anytime soon. That role falls to Sam, who tells Jon that Robb is at the head of an army marching south to war, and Jon faces yet another test of his oath: stay, or go and help his brother?

Maester Aemon AKA Aemon Targaryen
At least I didn't have to marry my sister up here

Maester Aemon summons him: Jon thinks it’s for another lecture on the conflict between love and duty – something he’s wrestling with and doesn’t want to hear about – but Aemon brings him up short with his own revelation. Aemon has been in Jon’s position, only he was older: Maester Aemon is  Aemon Targarygen, the great-uncle of Mad King Aerys (and thus Dany’s great-great-uncle). Aemon chose to stay with the Night’s Watch and his family lost their war, but will Jon choose his old family or his new one? And will it make a difference to the war either way?

“We all do our duty when there’s no cost to it….I will not tell you to stay or go. You must make that choice yourself. And live with it for the rest of your days – as I have” – Aemon


Speaking of the war: the Northern army needs to cross the Trident, but the Freys hold the crossing. The Freys are technically subordinate to the Tullys, but no-one expects Lord Frey to roll over for them, and Theon can’t keep shooting down their messenger ravens forever. Robb wants to go and negotiate, but Catelyn offers herself instead, and we get a glimpse inside the Twins, the Frey’s stronghold (did you spot it in the opening sequence?). Lord Frey, old, lecherous, and surrounded by a thunderous mass of children and miscellaneous descendants of various ages, plays tough with Catelyn. He feels her family has not treated him with the respect he deserves, plus she’s asking him to betray his oaths to the crown, and he’ll make Catelyn pay. As the sun is setting, she returns to the commanders with his terms.

Robb Stark looking confused
Catelyn: We're selling your 12-year-old sister in marriage! Robb: Ten-four. Catelyn: Also you. Robb:... I dunno if I am ready to commit (c/o @sarahreesbrenna's Twitter)

Lord Frey will allow them to cross and give them troops as long as his son Ollivar becomes Robb’s personal squire; Arya is to marry a Frey offspringlet (seven hells!); and Robb is to marry one of the Frey daughters after the war. Neither Robb nor Catelyn are pleased at this prospect, but Robb takes one for the team and agrees. Theon is highly amused.

Meanwhile, the Lannisters are discussing tactics around a well-stocked table. Tywin has decided to place Tyrion and the mountain men at the front of his attacking force:

“Surely there are ways to have me killed that would be less detrimental to the war effort?” ““ Tyrion

Tyrion retreats to his tent, where Bronn has found someone to take his mind off the imminent prospect of probable death in battle: Shae, a tall, dark, and handsome foreign prostitute. Tyrion details his terms, Shae agrees, and they later share some wine and a few laughs with Bronn. Tyrion prides himself on his cleverness, but he can’t figure Shae out. Bronn mentions something he’s heard about Tyrion – he used to be married. With a bit of persuasion, Tyrion tells the story:

As a teenager, he and Jaime saved a young girl, Tysha, from being raped, and Tyrion fell in love with her in the time it takes to eat three roast chickens and drink some wine. After they spent the night together, he found a septon to marry them, and they lived happily for a few weeks until Tywin finds out. Tywin then made Jaime tell Tyrion that it was all a set-up, that Tysha was paid, and made Tyrion watch as she is gang-raped by his soldiers.

Who wants to nominate Tywin for father of the decade? Bronn says he would have killed Tywin, but Shae is less sympathetic: Tyrion should have known Tysha was a prostitute.

Next morning, Tyrion and Shae are rudely awakened by Bronn: Robb’s army has made an unexpected move, and the battle is on. Tyrion asks Shae to cry for him if he dies, but she doesn’t seem too enthused, while Bronn offers some advice for Tyrion’s first battle:

Bronn: Stay low.

Tyrion: Stay low?

Bronn: If you’re lucky, no one will notice you.

Tyrion: I was born lucky.

He heads off and stirs up the mountain men but barely gets 10 feet before he’s knocked out by one of their hammers. He wakes up after the battle: a victory, but barely worth the fight; it was only two thousand Northerners.

Jaime is held at swordpoint by the Northerners
Can someone get this weirdo off my shoulder? He's creeping me out

On the other side, Catelyn waits for Robb to return, and he does, having captured Jaime Lannister (I’ll be honest, I nearly cried right along with her when Robb rode up with all his limbs intact and no blood visible). Jaime took down 10 men before he was captured and is still sprightly enough to offer Robb single combat. Robb doesn’t take the bait and warns his forces that they haven’t won yet: he sacrificed two thousand men to get Jaime, and they still haven’t freed Ned, got Sansa and Arya back, or liberated the North:

“If we do it your way, Kingslayer, you’d win. We’re not doing it your way” – Robb

Way over in Essos, Dany is finally looking plausibly pregnant, but Drogo isn’t looking at all well. He is feverish and falls off his horse, which sparks the first mutterings of mutiny from his bloodriders. Dany squeezes the sponge of authority for all it’s worth and makes the khalasar set up camp and get Mirri Maz Duur in to treat Drogo’s wound, but both she and Jorah know that it’s too late. The wound he received in last week’s leadership spat is massively infected, and Drogo is dying. Jorah urges her to leave; without Drogo, Dany has no position in the khalasar, and their baby will be a loose end that the next Khal will want to tidy up. Dany, romantically but cluelessly, insists she is staying with Drogo and begs Mirri to cure him. Mirri tells her that there is one spell, but it is blood magic and requires paying for life with death. Mirri has Drogo’s horse brought in and cuts its throat over Drogo’s twiching body, then orders everyone to leave the tent. No one must be there while she works the spell. Dany staggers outside, covered in blood, and gets thrown to the ground when she tries to stop Drogo’s second-in-command from entering the tent.

Close up of Dany, her face covered in blood
What is this mortality you speak of?

Jorah steps in, and after a brief fight, makes a convincing case for armour and a broadsword against a scimitar and no armour. The second-in-command is dead, but the fall has somehow thrown Dany into early labour. None of the Dothraki midwives will attend her, so Jorah picks her up and carries her back to Mirri in the tent…

And now, finally, to King’s Landing. The episode opened with Ned Stark,  breathing in the darkness, as Varys comes to visit him again. Varys tells him Cersei is willling to let him go to the Wall if he confesses. Ned is scornful and not afraid to die, but as Varys asks, is he afraid for his children? Sansa has pleaded for his life and Robb is marching south at the head of an army to free him. Varys could free him but won’t because that isn’t part of the role he’s playing. Varys wants peace and doesn’t care who keeps it – so what will Ned do now?

Later, Arya puts her dancing lessons to good use, catching pigeons in the city, but isn’t having much luck trading them for actual food. The bells of Baelor’s Sept begin to ring: Ned is being brought out in front of the people to confess to treason. From the platform, he sees Arya watching from the plinth of Baelor’s statue and manages to tell the Night’s Watchman from a few episodes ago, Yoren, by muttering “Baelor” to him as he’s dragged through the crowd.

head and shoulders view of Sansa on the platform
She who has the most elaborate hair wins, right? Right?

Sansa, proud that she’s managed to both save her father’s life and make a Moebius croissant out of her hair, is looking radiant on the platform and nods encouragingly as Ned begins his false confession. We can tell it’s killing him, but he finishes, and we wait for Joffrey’s decision. Everyone, including Cersei and Sansa, expects Joffrey to show mercy, but he’s anxious to make his mark, and disdaining “the weak hearts of women,” he sentences Ned to death. Arya draws her sword and fights through the crowd, only to be grabbed by Yoren; Sansa is screaming and restrained by the kingsguard; and Ned… Ned just breathes quietly and evenly until the sword comes down on his neck.

Sometimes, a hug doesn't make it all better.

Non-book readers – did you see it coming? How many tissues did you need?
Is Drogo next – and what would that mean for Dany? (Even if she knew, the fact that she’s not the only Targaryen in the village any more is not much help right now). And what in seven hells is going to happen next week, the final episode of the series?

Further reading and viewing: a brief discussion of sexual violence in the series; Seán Bean reflects on his character; io9 discusses the buying and selling of women in the series; and, if you think you can handle it, next week’s preview.

16 replies on “Breathe With Me: Game of Thrones Episode 9”

I just watched the episode (I was out of town, it was killing me!) and was hoping I’d come here and you’d tell me that the executioner missed or he wiggled out of it somehow. Please just tell me that they don’t kill Jamie Lannister in retaliation. I don’t think I could take it.

Robb is not as stupid as Joffrey, so **spoiler** Jaime is not killed in retaliation. If the previews are to be believed Catelyn gives him a few slaps, though.

Ned’s death kicks off practically every subsequent storyline, so storywise it’s awful but essential. I have the impression – based on hints from I think – that HBO are bringing Seán Bean back in flashbacks for an episode or two. Ned won’t be the last major character to be killed off, though.

I haven’t read the books, but I knew Ned was going to die because I inferred it from several comments in these recaps. I was dreading it but assumed it would happen this season. So upsetting! The entire episode was hard for me to watch – I’m kind of a bleeding heart, and all the violence – especially against women and animals – can be a bit gratuitous. I listened to the scene with Dany and the horse sacrifice with my eyes closed. By the time it got to the scene with Ned, I was rather devastated already.

I lurve Sean Bean, have seen him in almost every movie he’s been in, so I was disappointed to see him go. As always, the actress playing Cersai is brilliant. The look on her face with Joffrey declared that Ned would be killed was priceless. You can tell she never meant for it to get this far, that in actuality she may actually be fond of the Stark family, but her thirst for power and control has taken them all down a disastrous road that may just be their downfall.

The actress who plays Shae is fucking hot. I just had to say that. I couldn’t quit staring at her eyes, and that accent! Rawr!

Cersei got hardly any screen time in this episode: but yes, the look on her face when she realised her favourite son was not going to be her obedient puppet king was amazing, all the more so because it was fleeting. That’s something the writers have flagged repeatedly, especially for the young male characters: the line between being a child and being an adult. Robb offers an interesting contrast to Joffrey in that.

Shae is played by a German actress, Sibel Kilkelli. I was actually surprised they used her, as I’d though perhaps they would’ve used Ros as a replacement for Shae’s character in the books. But her age and her self-possession make her more interesting than Shae in the books and makes me think/hope that her character has more to her. I love that Tyrion couldn’t figure her out.

As a non-book reader I had picked up on Ned’s death from other media but it was still shocking and heartbreaking. Seeing Arya being comforted by some stranger also added massively to the sadness. Before Ned was killed I thought Arya was going to sneak her way up there and assassinate Joffrey. Joffrey ordering the execution of Ned seems to be the beginning of Cersai’s downfall.

I really don’t want Drogo to die but I think that is the direction we are heading and I am hoping that Dany Dragonpants will have some special powers to protect her from her disloyal sbjects.

Am I crazy for thinking Catelyn said something about her having to marry someone too?

I don’t think there was anything mentioned about Catelyn: firstly because I didn’t hear it and secondly because Ned wasn’t yet dead when she talked to Lord Frey. There was something about her father not deigning to marry any of his relatives to Lord Frey’s, though.

Seeing Sean Bean die as Ned was even more harrowing than reading it. I can’t wait to talk to my folks about this episode, as they haven’t read the books and I imagine will be quite shocked, especially since he’s a big name actor.

Re: sexual violence on the show. I have thought about it a lot and my position is that I don’t find it offensive in this case, because to my mind, it doesn’t seem sexualized –it’s not supposed to be titillating. I am far more bothered by the scenes, like the already infamous fingerbanging one during Littlefinger’s exposition scene the other week, that are just gratuitously naked women presented to keep the viewer’s attention. Same old, same old, ya know?

Also on sexual violence, a question for book readers: what do you make of the decision to leave off the ending of Tyrion’s story about his wife? SPOILERS SPOILERS (well, maybe, if it comes up later in the show) If you remember, in the book, after Tywin had his soldiers rape her, he had Tyrion do the same, and then give her a gold coin “because Lannisters are worth more.” I never liked that in the book–it’s hard for me to imagine a decent dude being able to keep an erection in that sort of situation, and I love Tyrion–and I wonder if that’s why it was omitted, to make Tyrion more sympathetic?

Yes. I don’t mind that they have dialled the explicit sexual violence down a bit – to be honest I don’t trust TV makers to make the difference between sex and sexual violence explicit e.g.: CSI-type shows.
I imagine that was why that part was left out. Without going into educational detail about sexual coercion, I’m not sure what else they could have done.

I though they did it really really well. I loved that they started and ended the episode with Ned’s breathing. Though I was never as upset by this as I was by events in the later books, when I had to stop reading for a few weeks due to being traumatised.

Leave a Reply